Listen to "Counterfactuals: The Sensational 1876 Election" on Spreaker.

Counterfactuals: The Sensational 1876 Election

On today’s episode we talk about one of the most fraught elections in American history, where violence, intimidation and outright fraud precipitated a constitutional crisis - the 1876 election between Rutherford B. Hayes and Samuel Tilden.

Jan 13, 2026| 01:01:14
Other Podcasts
1
Counterfactuals: Samoan Crisis of 1889
2
Counterfactuals: Wine Extinction
3
Counterfactuals: The Mutiny That Almost Lost the Revolution
4
Counterfactuals: The Battle of the Bulge at Elsenborn Ridge
5
Counterfactuals: The Last Invasion of Britain
6
Counterfactuals: What if the Chicken Didn’t Cross the Road?
7
Counterfactuals: USS Boston and the New Navy
8
Counterfactuals: The Three Kingdoms – or not?
9
Counterfactuals: Just How Foundational IS Concrete?
10
Counterfactuals: Roosevelt and Churchill at Christmas, 1941
11
Counterfacutals: WWI and The Battle of the Gulf of Riga
12
Counterfactuals: Confederate Espionage
13
Counterfactuals: The Passenger Pigeon’s World
14
Counterfactuals: Did Ketchup Save the World?
15
Counterfactuals: 1983, The World’s Most Dangerous Year
16
Counterfactuals: Cannae and Hannibal
17
Counterfactuals: Task Force 34 and Leyte Gulf
18
Counterfactuals: The Great Lisbon Earthquake
19
Counterfactuals: The Axumite Empire
20
Counterfactuals: The Battle of Tsushima and the 20th Century
21
Counterfactuals: What if we Used a Different Calendar?
22
Counterfactuals- The White Ship and the Anarchy
23
Counterfactuals: The Forgotten WWII Battle of Thala
24
Counterfactuals: A World Without Potatoes
25
Counterfactuals: Viking North America
26
Counterfactuals: Westward Expansion and Ashley’s 100
27
Counterfactuals: What if There Were no Transistors?
28
Counterfactuals: The Dmitriads
29
Counterfactuals: 732 – The End of Christian Europe?
30
Counterfactuals: A World Without Cats
31
Counterfactuals: The Inca
32
Counterfactuals: Alexandrian India
33
Counterfactuals: 1815 Tambora Eruption
34
Counterfactuals: The Duels of Alexander Hamilton
35
Counterfactuals: Death of a President Part 2
36
Counterfactuals: Death of A President Part 1
37
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
38
A History of Making the Perfect Smile
39
The American Civil War on the Water
40
Modern Marvels: Celluloid and Transistors
41
Hurricanes that Made History
42
Volcanoes: Vesuvius & Tambora
43
Movie Stars in WWII
44
Explorers: Magellan and Bering
45
New York Engineering: The Secret Subway and Brooklyn Bridge
46
The “Proto-Mafia”
47
Stolen Art: The “Just Judges” and Goya’s Wellington
48
Grape Blights and Grasshopper Plagues
49
Governors Assassinated
50
Pearl Harbor: The first Shot and the Aftermath
51
Hygiene History: Soap and Semmelweiss
52
Mad Monarchs: Charles VI and Ludwig II
53
Ancient Egypt: The Pyramids and the Silver Pharoah
54
Terror in the Air: TACA 110 and China Airlines 006
55
The P-38 Lightning
56
New York Riots
57
Forgotten Naval Battles of WWI
58
“My Name is Aaron Burr”
59
What You Didn’t Learn in School: Continents and the Seven Seas
60
Alexander the Great
61
Women in WWII: WASP and Virginia Hall
62
Forgotten Colonies: Popham and Panama
63
Exploited History: Slavery and Human Zoos
64
Dog Tales
65
Industrial Invention: Elevators and Vending Machines
66
Bitter Cold in the Gilded Age: The Long Winter and the Lady Franklin Bay Expedition
67
Christmas and Candy in the American Military
68
Stories of Pearl Harbor
69
Bread, Berries, and the Government
70
Animals of the Great War: Pigeons and Mercy Dogs
71
Forgotten American Mints: From New Orleans to Manila
72
The American Civil War Trans-Mississippi Theater: Wilson’s Creek and Prairie Grove
73
Hurricane History: The Great Miami Hurricane and Doc McFadden
74
Cold War Defense: The DEW Line and Texas Towers
75
Disasters: Railway Accidents
76
The Eastern Front: Fortresses, Night Witches, and Fake Guardsmen
77
WWII Special Forces: Los Baños and Makin Island
78
Television and the Don Lee Broadcasting System
79
Pirates! 2: Barbarossa, Port Royal, and Jamestown
80
US Borders: The Missouri Bootheel and The Toldeo War
81
D-Day Heroes
82
A.P. Giannini and The History of Credit
83
Forgotten Peoples: the Itza Maya and Axum
84
1970s Car Disasters: The Dale and the Vega
85
Coasties: Stories of the USCGCs Tampa and Icarus
86
Lines on the Road and the Wheels that Drive on them
87
Two 19th Century Kates
88
Aerial Hijinks: 3 Wild Stories
89
Civil War Freedom Fighters: Robert Smalls and Abraham Galloway
90
The Mafia Beer Wars: Dean O’Bannion and Calvin Goddard
91
Supernatural True Crime: The Greenbrier Ghost and Bridget Cleary
92
Weird Wars: China’s War on Sparrows and the Pastry War
93
A History Guy Christmas: Nutcrackers and Christmas Trees
94
Useful Resources: The Histories of Helium and Asbestos
95
Forgotten Fruit History: Bananas and Oranges
96
Tin Can Ships: Destroyers and the First Submarines Sunk by the US in Both World Wars
97
History Lost: The 1890 Census and the 1973 NPRC Fire
98
Pawns and Princes of Russia
99
Weird Weather: 1974 Tornado Super Outbreak, 1943 Black Hills Record, and the Great White Hurricane
100
The War Before the War: The Undeclared War and the Reuben James, WWII Iceland, and the ‘Phoney War’
101
Nuclear Near Misses: The Palomares Incident and the Wrench That Nearly Blew Up Arkansas
102
Tales of the Gilded Age: Cleveland’s Secret Surgery and the Harrison Horror
103
Pilotless Planes: Planes that Landed Themselves, the L-8 Blimp, and Taffy Holden
104
War Time Heroes: Mary Edwards Walker and Tom Custer
105
Tales of Cow: Steaks and US History and “Sir Loin” of Beef
106
Unique Animals: Pere David’s Deer and Okapi Johnstoni
107
True Crime Trials: Daniel Sickles’ Temporary Insanity and the murder of Gulielma Sands
108
Fantastic Frauds: Titanic Thompson and Stanley Weyman
109
A tortoise, a horse, and a bear, oh my! : Timothy, Sgt. Reckless, and Winnie the Pooh
110
Cold War Chronicles: Able Archer and Oleg Gordievsky
111
Mystery Murders: The Saxtown Axe Murders and the “Servant Girl Annihilator”
112
Pirates! : The Wreck of the Whydah and Albert Hicks
113
Cats and Dogs: Housecats and Civilization and Able Seaman Just Nuisance
114
Unsung Heroes: Video Game Pioneer and “Brave Bessie”
115
True Stories of the Wild West: A Bandit Who Fell off His Horse and Soapy Smith
116
Historical Cryptids: Beast of Gevaudan and Washington’s Eagle
117
Aviation Accidents: Fall From an SR-71 and the Valkyrie’s mid-air Collision

Recent Pocasts

All Podcasts
Counterfactuals: Wine Extinction
Jan 27, 2026   |   59:45
Counterfactuals: The Sensational 1876 Election
Jan 13, 2026   |   01:01:14
Counterfactuals: The Mutiny That Almost Lost the Revolution
Dec 30, 2025   |   01:04:48
Counterfactuals: The Battle of the Bulge at Elsenborn Ridge
Dec 16, 2026   |   01:07:06
Counterfactuals: The Last Invasion of Britain
Dec 2, 2025   |   01:01:10
Counterfactuals: What if the Chicken Didn’t Cross the Road?
Nov 18, 2025   |   01:09:53

Support The History Guy

If you love history, this is the channel to support! Generous contributions from supporters allow The History Guy team to continue creating the snippets of forgotten history that have been seen by viewers all around the world. You’ll be supporting this record of the past that helps to inform our present. Making The History Guy takes time, effort, and equipment. It is history that deserves your help!

Memberships
Donations
Shout Outs